De Grading
Grading is so exciting. No, really. It is. It really is. Granted, if I were the type who takes pleasure in others’ pain, it would be more so. Or in my own pain, for that matter. I understand that theory behind the concept of creative spelling, but I think that creative capitalization takes it a step too far. English isn’t that close to German.
Still, grading does have its exciting points. For instance, there’s that moment of relief and reassurance in the first or second paragraph of an unusually coherent essay when you begin to realize that it’s an A-level exam. What generates excitement, though, is the hopeful suspicion that it could even be an A+ essay. In this case, no longer am I on the lookout for glaring anachronisms (sorry, Thomas Jefferson and Henry Ford were not best of friends, and Vietnam did not happen during World War II... I wish I was making this up) or trying to decide how to rate a technically correct but disappointingly short essay. Instead, it’s the details that matter now: Is there an introduction and a conclusion? Has the writer picked up on the more subtle concepts (i.e., things in the world are not, unfortunately, either all good or all bad—things like monoculture and GM foods have both benefits and drawbacks, surprise!)?
I feel like I’m rooting for the student, like a spectator at a sporting event, fearing the fatal mistake that will knock it out of the A+ running. But at the same time, I’m also supposed to be the objective referee. So, I kindly ask my “spectator side” to step aside for a while, but I can still hear it over my shoulder, whispering to itself: “Is it true? Did I hear right, that this essay might be The One? The fabled... *hushed tone of reverence* ...A+?”
Referee-Self, distracted by the whispers, glares at Spectator-Self over her shoulder. Spectator-Self shrinks away, but is too eaten by curiosity and suspense to be so rudely cut out of the loop. She hires Sports-Announcer-Self to relay the play-by-play:
“Here it is, folks, the essay you’ve all been waiting for! It’s looking good, it has potential, but what do you think, Bob? Does it have what it takes to go all the way to the A+? It’s definitely A material we have here, folks, so it should be an exciting read, but if you want to see whether this paper wins its way to the top, stay tuned! Just a few weeks ago this essayist was considering trading Ag History for some other class out on the Arts Quad, I think we here in the ag school can be glad that negotiations fell through. –Wait, the referee has halted the reading... Oh, that’ll hurt, Bob! We’ve just seen a reference to the first cow calorimeter being invented at Minnesota instead of Wisconsin! Too bad! But let’s get a close-up of the ref. Will this minor mistake end this paper’s bid for the Plus? The ref has raised her pen... she hesitates... She’s scribbling in the margin... and she’s continuing on! I see no minus signs! Repeat, no minus signs! This paper is still in! Can we get a replay of that? What suspense! Phew! Well, with that, we’d better cool down and head into halftime with a word from our sponsor, Rold Gold’s new Dipped Twists chocolate covered pretzels. The papers and the ref are leaving the field for today’s halftime show, featuring the Ag History Cheer Squad and their mascot, Bessie!”
When Referee-Self returns from her lunch break, Sports-Announcer-Self has left, maybe to go look up exam statistics or hunt down a student’s autograph. As soon as she resumes grading, though, yet another voice pipes up, this time from Political-Correspondent-Self:
“So far, this essay has managed to duck below the radar of the worst of the negative campaigning. Critics have pointed out a few relatively tame points of controversy, such as the unusually wide margin throughout the second essay and two minor apostrophe infractions, but that doesn’t seem to be hurting it in the polls. It has been negotiating the gauntlet of questioning carefully and knowledgeably, and it has been taking the results of the recent Study Group very seriously. In short, this essay has charisma, it has confidence, and it’s wiling to tackle the hard questions. And these are all qualities that appeal to graders. We just might have our next A+ here!”
At this point, Referee-Self tossed the last blue book (which, incidentally, are white, not green) onto the “done” pile and joyfully fell onto her bed.
But with all this excitement, who could possibly sleep?
Posted Threesummers
at 22:16 EST